This week guest writer Charlotte Morrish explores animal law in The Cayman Islands. Introduction The Cayman Islands is a British Overseas Territory in the Caribbean, consisting of three islands which are home to approximately 80,000 people. Being small islands with limited agriculture, the legal framework pertaining to animals is primarily aimed at protecting native species (notably the blue iguana) and preventing cruelty to other animals, the majority of which are cats and dogs. Like many of its Caribbean neighbours, the Cayman Islands is home to numerous unwanted companion animals, and cultural attitudes against spay and neuter and in favour of allowing dogs to roam , for example, expound the overpopulation issues.       With a substantial expatriate population due to its status as a global financial services centre, and a thriving tourism industry, the Cayman Islands government collected a record-breaking CI$1 billion in revenue in 2022, resulting in a substantial operating surplus . Cayman is one of the world’s highest ranked countries based on real GDP per capita . However, despite the country’s relative wealth, poor animal welfare remains a significant challenge. The Animal Welfare and Control Services Agency falls within the remit of the Department of Agriculture but operates with limited personnel and resource (a Freedom of Information ('FOI') Request Response from Department of Agriculture 22 November 2023 confirmed that, as at that time, they only employed one Animal Welfare Officer and the budget for the Animal Welfare and Control Services agency was KYD$14,400 (approx. £14,000), meaning that the burden of addressing the overpopulation of cats and dogs, and the consequent animal welfare problems, falls largely on local animal charities. A lack of suitable homes due to pervasive 'no-pet' rules in the rental market and a transient population exacerbate the overpopulation issues. The Cayman Islands Humane Society , the Islands’ largest animal welfare charity and operator of the Islands’ only animal shelter, rescued 540 dogs and cats in 2023. It also conducted 906 spay/neuter surgeries, treated 139 animals for heartworm and administered 3620 vaccinations and de-wormers .  Animal welfare law The primary piece of legislation concerning animals, including their welfare, in the Cayman Islands is the Animals Act (2024 Revision)  ('the Act'). The Act is divided into a number of parts dealing with particular areas including: Import and Export of Animals; Control of Diseases of Animals; Improvement of farmed animals; Licensing of Dogs; Nuisances by, and Control of, Animals; Protection of Animals and Wild Life. The Act also establishes an Animal Welfare Advisory Committee (section 66), comprising six members including the Director of the Department of Agriculture, a member from the Cayman Islands Humane Society, the Cayman Horse Association, the Agricultural Society, the Police, and a member of the general public with a demonstrated interest in animal welfare. The Committee is mandated to meet at least once every two months (section 69) and is responsible for, amongst other things, advising the minister responsible for agriculture on policy matters relating to the care of animals, and educating the public on the care of animals (section 67). Sections 70-77 of the Act are concerned with preventing cruelty to animals. Section 70(1) creates the offence of cruelty and specifies the ways in which this may be committed, including by 'wantonly or unreasonably' causing unnecessary suffering (section 70(1)(b)) and by tethering or confining an animal in such a way as to cause unnecessary suffering (section 70(1)(f)). Section 70(3) goes some way to imposing a positive duty, but stops short of being akin to the UK equivalent in section 9 of the Animal Welfare Act. It requires that the 'owner of an animal who leaves an animal on premises shall ensure that there is a person on the premises or a person who will visit the premises to maintain that animal, and that the animal- (a) has access to drinking water and food; (b) has access to accommodation which is suitable as regards drainage, size, cleanliness and ventilation; (c) is able to move freely; and (d) has reasonable shelter against the sun and rain.' The use of the word 'maintain' suggests that the Act is focused on ensuring the basic survival needs of the animal, rather than its welfare needs.  Despite the Cayman Islands Government stating that all animals 'are entitled to a standard level of care… in accordance with the principles of the Five Freedom ' the legislation falls short of enshrining the Five Freedoms and there is a notable absence of any requirement for animals to be able to express normal behaviours. An area of significant concern in terms of animal welfare is responsible dog ownership. Here, there is a conflict between equally concerning issues: dogs who are left to roam the streets freely, and dogs who are tethered outside 24/7. The Department of Agriculture’s own guidance recommends tethering dogs instead of allowing them to roam , but this is perhaps at odds with the reference to freedom of movement under section 70(3)(c) and the offence of cruelty by tethering which causes unnecessary suffering under section 70(1)(f). All the aforementioned offences are triable summarily and punishable by a four thousand dollar fine and imprisonment for one year.  Other offences in the Act include fighting or baiting (section 71), transporting an animal in a manner which causes avoidable or unnecessary pain or suffering (section 72), causing unnecessary suffering whilst killing (section 74), and tail docking of horses (section 75), all of which are triable summarily and punishable by a five hundred dollar fine and imprisonment for six months. Of particular concern is the lack of an enforced licensing regime for breeders. Despite section 29 of the Act making it an offence to breed 'pet animals' without a licence (punishable by a fine of up to ten thousand dollars) the government was slow to implement a licensing regime , and in response to an FOI request in October 2023 asking how many breeding licenses were held at that time, the response was 'assume nil'. This lack of effective oversight and enforcement has significant implications for the overpopulation issues, and for the welfare of bred animals.  Recent developments In February 2023 a new set of Regulations came into effect pertaining to 'alien species ' which include, inter alia, feral cats. In fact, the definition of 'alien species' is very broadly drawn to essentially include any animal not present on the Islands prior to their discovery by humans (and on one reading, could even include humans!). The regulations make it illegal to feed these alien species (section 18) or to trap, neuter and release them back into the wild (section 17). The effect is therefore to mandate the necessary suffering of feral cats but prohibiting members of the public from feeding them, and further to prohibit 'trap neuter release' programmes by animal welfare organisations. The regulations also permit private persons to destroy alien species themselves, including feral cats.  The regulations were condemned by the Cayman Islands Humane Society  and widely criticised by the public. They are currently stayed pending a judicial review by another animal welfare NPO, Feline Friends, on the grounds that they are unlawful, irrational and incompatible with the Cayman Islands Constitution. Leave was granted and the full hearing is awaited.   Enforcement Despite a general lack of enforcement of animal cruelty offences in the Cayman Islands, according to a statement from the Government, the community 'wants to see animals better protected and appropriate consequences administered for those who fail to comply with their legal requirements ' . In a recent case involving a dog called Wilbur who was found extremely emaciated and died shortly after being rescued, the owner was sentenced to five months’ imprisonment following a trial. In sentencing the defendant for an offence under section 70(1) of the Animals Act, Magistrate McFarlane observed that this was 'one of the most serious cases of animal neglect that she had seen and that the sentence was designed to 'send a clear message, that of deterrence ' . Another case which received widespread local attention concerned the death of a police dog, K9 Baron, who died after being left in the sun without access to food or water when a police constable failed to raise a sliding gate separating the indoor and outdoor sections of the kennel. The constable was acquitted of a charge under section 70(1)(b), the Magistrate having found that the reference to 'wantonly and unreasonably' in the statement of offence required the prosecution to prove ill intent on the part of the defendant, a burden which they failed to discharge in the circumstances of this case .  Despite the acquittal in K9 Baron’s case, the investigation and prosecution of these two offences demonstrate an increased public demand that animal welfare laws will be enforced.  Conclusion Notwithstanding its relative wealth, the Cayman Islands faces similar animal welfare challenges to other small island nations. Whilst it benefits from having animal welfare laws in place, including to establish an Animal Welfare Advisory Committee, and a robust judicial system, with very few cases resulting in prosecution to date, the effectiveness of this legislation has not been properly explored through the Courts. In any event, there appears to be scope for significant improvement in the protections afforded to animals in the Cayman Islands through further legislation which expressly enshrines the Five Freedoms, and, as with the UK, expressly recognises animal sentience. Getting advice This post is not legal advice and should not be relied on as such. If you require legal advice on animal protection laws, please contact info@advocates-for-animals.com .

29 November 2022 Following the launch of The Animal Law Foundation, we think it is important to explain how the new charity will work, particularly in relation to Advocates for Animals and Advocates for Animals’ much valued clients. Advocates for Animals is so proud of all the work it does with its clients and would like to provide reassurance that this work and service will remain entirely unaffected, save for perhaps being bolstered by another animal law entity with a new pool of expertise. How The Animal law Foundation started Through the work conducted at the law firm Advocates for Animals, it has become apparent that the laws that are passed through Parliament are grossly under-enforced in practice, rendering the value of those laws questionable at best and redundant at worst. Following this realisation, a new venture was required to monitor the implementation and enforcement of animal law. Having secured some funding and actively seeking additional support, The Animal Law Foundation will research neglected areas of animal law and where appropriate instruct solicitors to bring challenges to ensure that any system in place to protect animals, functions as it should. The UK still has some of the best animal welfare laws in the world, yet the opportunity for vast improvements contained within these laws is rarely explored. Through exploring these opportunities, the whole system for animals can be improved and set global examples. For its first groundbreaking project, it has co-authored and published a report with Animal Equality UK called The Enforcement Problem, which explores the issues surrounding the enforcement of farmed animal welfare laws. The findings include: Fewer than 3% of UK farms were inspected (2.95%) Upon receiving a complaint, just half (50.45%) of farms were then inspected Of those inspections, approximately one-third (31.38%) identified non-compliance on the same site Just 0.33% of farms were prosecuted following initial complaints of non-compliance The report received coverage in The Guardian and The Mirror and can be found here: https://animallawfoundation.org/reports How the relationship will work with Advocates for Animals and its clients Advocates for Animals remains a professional law firm that works with its clients to assist with animal protection issues. In the event The Animal Law Foundation identifies a legal challenge, The Animal Law Foundation may become a client of Advocates for Animals. The Animal Law Foundation will not duplicate the legal work Advocates for Animals does for its clients, but rather it will explore neglected areas. It is of vital importance that the laws that exist to protect animals are understood and applied. 'Despite their sentience and all the incredible attributes animals possess, they are extremely vulnerable in our society, both at the hands of commercial interests and the sadistic. It is therefore essential that a framework is in place to prevent certain treatment. You do not have to be an animal lover or an activist in this area to recognise that animals deserve protection under the law and that those laws need to be enforced. How can we justify the proclamation that we are a nation of animal lovers and that we have some of the highest animal welfare standards on farms and slaughterhouses in the world, if these standards only exist on paper?' Edie Bowles

As we approach what we expect to be our biggest year yet, we want to take this moment to reflect on another year at Advocates for Animals and all the growth we have seen. Some highlights from 2022 include: We won the first private prosecution we have brought regarding cruelty towards dogs. You can find out more here We were granted permission for two judicial reviews against the government, one to challenge fast growing chickens bred for meat and one challenging cosmetic testing on animals. Permission is achieved in only 5% of cases. You can find out more here and here We provided legal assistance to help close a huge reptile market with significant animal welfare concerns. You can find out more here We provided legal advice to almost all of the major animal groups in the UK We had our work featured in major news outlets, including The Guardian , The BBC and The Mirror We have welcomed new members to our growing team We welcomed The Animal Law Foundation to the UK animal law family 2022 was our best year yet, but we are determined to make 2023 even better. To provide a taster for 2023: We are advising on two prosecutions regarding cruelty on farms We will be attending the hearings for our two judicial reviews We will be working with The Animal Law Foundation to prevent systemic illegality We will be welcoming new team members. Find out more here Thank you to all of those who support us, you have made this vision a reality. We couldn't do it without you. 2023 here we come!

Advocates for Animals, the UK’s first Animal Law firm, has won Boutique Law Firm of the Year from the prestigious Legal Business Awards 2023. On 19 September 2023 Advocates for Animals, amongst a group of esteemed legal professionals gathered at a glitzy event in Mayfair, London, won an award granted by Legal Business. Other winners included TLT, Dentons, Latham and Watkins and Macfarlanes. This award not only recognises Advocates for Animals and the vital work the firm does for animal protection, but it puts animal law on the map as a distinct and important legal discipline worthy of respect. This in itself is groundbreaking and The Legal Business Awards should be commended for recognising this. The practice of animal law has been present in other countries like the US and Canada for decades, yet in the UK it has only really gained momentum since Advocates for Animals was launched in 2019. The UK is a nation of animal lovers and often pats itself on the back for its relatively high standards and animal laws in the statute books, but with a lack of lawyers specialising in animal law these laws were left to be grossly underenforced and interpreted in a way that has not always had the animals’ best interests at heart. Advocates for Animals has worked across a variety of cases, all with the intention of ensuring that animal laws are applied in practice. It is currently involved in a high profile judicial review challenging the UK government over the use of fast growing chickens that make up 90% of the chicken meat in the UK; these chickens experience a range of health and welfare issues. 'We are over the moon to have won this award. Animal law is not easy—fighting to help animals in the courts and witnessing the cruelty is hard. This award is a reminder that change is happening, people see the value in this important work. We would like to dedicate this award to our wonderful clients who truly have made this possible and most importantly the animals who we will continue to fight for.' - Edie Bowles, Managing Director, Advocates for Animals 'Edie and her team are thoroughly deserving of this award. The firm’s work is truly integral to the animal protection movement; thanks to their team of experts, animal groups and activists are now better positioned than ever before to recommend robust legislation, publicly scrutinise the government and corporate animal welfare policies, conduct powerful investigations into animal industries and more. By providing a high-quality and affordable legal service in this space, animal groups and activists are able to make informed decisions that, in turn, spare animals from suffering. Awareness of animal protection is growing at pace and, thanks to the work of Advocates for Animals, it is also growing in its legal knowledge too.' Abi Penny, Executive Director, Animal Equality (client of Advocates for Animals We would like to dedicate this award to our wonderful clients who truly have made this possible and most importantly the animals who we will continue to fight for.

As we end an incredible year and welcome a new one, we want to take this moment to reflect on another successful year at Advocates for Animals and all that has been achieved to help animals and professionalise animal law.  Some of our highlights from 2023 include: We were delighted to win the prestigious award: Boutique Law Firm Of The Year   We continue to represent The Humane League in a high profile appeal against the use of fast growing chickens We won a case that chipped away at the property status of animals (more information to follow)  We spoke and attended conferences all over the world  We have welcomed new members to our growing team  We have received widespread media attention for our work: The Gazette , Plant Based News , The Mirror , and  The Guardian   We continue to provide legal advice to almost all of the major animal groups in the UK 2023 far exceeded our expectations and here is to even more wins for the animals in 2024. We have an exciting year ahead, including several hearings, including in the Court of Appeal and the Information Tribunal. We will be working with The Animal Law Foundation challenging the legality of boiling lobsters alive. Thank you to all of those who support us, you have made this vision a reality. We couldn't do it without you. 2024 here we come!

When it comes to design, the Wix blog has everything you need to create beautiful posts that will grab your reader's attention. Check out our essential design features. Choose from 8 stunning layouts Your Wix Blog comes with 8 beautiful layouts. From your blog's settings, choose the layout that’s right for you. For example, a tiled layout is popular for helping visitors discover more posts that interest them. Or, choose a classic single column layout that lets readers scroll down and see your post topics one by one. Every layout comes with the latest social features built in. Readers can easily share posts on social networks like Facebook and Twitter and view how many people have liked a post, made comments and more. Add media to your posts When creating your posts you can: Upload images or GIFs Embed videos and music Create galleries to showcase a media collection Customize the look of your media by making it widescreen or small and easily align media inside your posts. Hashtag your posts Love to #hashtag? Good news! You can add tags (#vacation #dream #summer) throughout your posts to reach more people. Why hashtag? People can use your hashtags to search through content on your blog and find the content that matters to them. So go ahead and #hashtag away!

With Wix Blog, you’re not only sharing your voice with the world, you can also grow an active online community. That’s why the Wix blog comes with a built-in members area - so that readers can easily sign easily up to become members of your blog. What can members do? Members can follow each other, write and reply to comments and receive blog notifications. Each member gets their own personal profile page that they can customize. Tip: You can make any member of your blog a writer so they can write posts for your blog. Adding multiple writers is a great way to grow your content and keep it fresh and diversified. Here’s how to do it: Head to your Member’s Page Search for the member you want to make a writer Click on the member’s profile Click the 3 dot icon ( ⠇) on the Follow button Select Set as Writer

We’ve made it quick and convenient for you to manage your blog from anywhere. In this blog post we’ll share the ways you can post to your Wix Blog. Blogging from Your Wix Blog Dashboard On the dashboard, you have everything you need to manage your blog in one place. You can create new posts, set categories and more. To head to your Dashboard, open the Wix Editor and click on Blog > Posts. Blogging from Your Published Site Did you know that you can blog right from your published website? After you publish your site, go to your website’s URL and login with your Wix account. There you can write and edit posts, manage comments, pin posts and more! Just click on the 3 dot icon ( ⠇) to see all the things you can do. #bloggingtips #WixBlog